Blogposts

Listen with our Hearts

09-15-2024Weekly ReflectionFr. Leonard F. Villa

In a video message accompanying his prayer intention for September, Pope Francis prays that "each of us might listen with our hearts to the cry of the earth and of the victims of environmental disasters and climate change, making a personal commitment to care for the world we inhabit." In a press release accompanying the Pope’s video-message, Cardinal Michael Czerny, S.J., says, “Creation is groaning. Its suffering is caused by humans who were originally its guardian and are now its subjugator”. Concern and care for the environment is one thing the claim of climate change (rising temperatures) caused by humans is another. Commentators tend to claim every extreme weather-event is being caused by human produced climate change. However, if every such event is climate-change, then nothing is climate change and we enter the realm of ideology rather than science.

There are other factors in extreme weather events, the disorder of creation and nature, NOT caused by human beings. Scripture in Romans 18:22-23 explains “groaning in creation” this way: 22 We know that the whole creation has been groaning together as it suffers together the pains of labor, 23 and not only the creation, but we ourselves, who have the first fruits of the Spirit, groan inwardly while we wait for adoption, the redemption of our bodies. The meaning of this is explained by another passage of Scripture 2 Peter 3: 13 But, in accordance with his promise, we wait for new heavens and a new earth, where righteousness dwells. A young priest Fr. Joachim Heimerl recently lamented: When was the last time you heard anything about the church's doctrine of creation? Hardly in politics and the media, and certainly not in the church's preaching either. There is nothing more in it than a lukewarm commitment to "preserving creation"; there is no mention of the "almighty Creator.” Belief in an impending "climate catastrophe" has seamlessly replaced belief in creation.

The claim of human-caused-climate-change is a scientific hypothesis. There are pros and cons. You usually hear about the pros but no cons in the media. It is not binding Catholic teaching nor could it be. The Pope’s competence is not in climate science nor can he impose it. His task is Church unity while guarding and explaining the teachings of the Church on faith and morals. There is scientific evidence and there is climate ideology. For climate ideologues if you question climate change, you are labeled a “climate denier” as if human-caused-climate-change is absolutely proven scientifically. It has not been and reputable climate scientists, who challenge the climate-change-narrative are often ignored especially by the media. Scientific consensus is not necessarily science. Science is based on empirical evidence not consensus.

Why an ideology? Consider this: Long before COVID, the 2019- shutdown, the masks, the quarantines, the constant government health edicts about what people can and cannot do, censuring people questioning the narrative, inflicting damage on people’s lives, was already forseen in 2013 by Patrick Zylberman in a book called Tempêtes microbiennes, (Microbial Storms) published by Gallimard in France It was never translated into English. It describes the process whereby biosecurity was becoming an essential component of State and international political-strategy and control! Philosopher George Agamben pointed out this strategy as nothing less than using bio-terror as a governing technique using worst-case-scenarios. Agamben summarizes Zylberman’s thesis as follows: setup, adopt, order:

-set up, based on possible risk, a fictitious scenario; present it in such a way to favor government-control in an extreme situation (You could add bad computer models and/or assumptions as part of the fiction.)
-adopt the worst-case-scenario as a governing-principle of political calculation
-order the body of citizens enforcing maximum adherence to government mandates, producing a super civic-mindedness, in which, the obligations imposed are presented as proofs of love of neighbor. Remember social-distancing? Thus the citizen has not simply a right to bio-security, but by law the guarantee of bio-security. What Zylberman described as a possibility in 2013 became reality in 2019.

The same thing is being attempted by climate-change-ideologues via politics: the government determines the car you drive, what you eat, or cannot eat (eg. insects instead of dairy or meat!) because of government determination of the effect on the environment based on a hypothesis which government says is certain. We are living through something Antonio Gramsci imagined (see John Lennon’s song Imagine) a society that stripped itself of religious belief and Western traditions and values, turbocharged by a Marxist-Machiavellian notion that “reduces all to politics, to the art of governing men, of assuring their permanent consensus. It is all about control. (emphasis added) He also saw socialism as the “religion” that would overwhelm Christianity. He said socialism will triumph by an infiltration of schools, universities, churches, and the media, by transforming the consciousness of society. Sadly his imagined society is before us. See Big Intell by J. Michael Waller Angelo Codevilla https://claremontreviewofbooks.com/the-rise-of-political-correctness/

In the Catechism of the Church we find under the First Commandment: Idolatry not only refers to false pagan worship. It remains a constant temptation to faith. Idolatry consists of making a god of what is not God. Man commits idolatry whenever he honors and reveres a creature in place of God. (#2113) We are stewards of the environment not gods over the environment. (emphasis added) God gave Adam the responsibility to “keep” the Garden and to represent Him in His creation. But what gives nature value is not that God is in every tree and plant; it is that God created every tree and plant. God is outside of, and greater than, nature. Frank Lloyd Wright, the noted architect of a previous generation commented: “Water can never rise higher than its source. Whatever man might build could never reflect more than he is.” In other words, as great as the creation is, the Creator must be greater than His creation. Human beings are not gods nor will they ever be despite the continuing repetition of the original sin by various self-styled revolutionaries who seek to mold creation and humanity in their image and likeness through raw political power.

Pantheism is the belief that God consists of everyone and everything. Whether a tree, a mountain, the universe, or you, all of it is God. Pantheism is found in many “nature” religions and is held by many New Age followers. In contrast, the Word of God reveals a God Who is outside of His Creation yet intimately involved in it. He created it, transcends it, and controls it. Nature has value because it reflects the glory of God, not because it is God. We can see God through nature, through the world He has created. It was meant to be a voice to all humanity (Psalm 19). But God is not nature and nature is not God. The result of thinking of nature as God and every man as being part of the divine is that men worship nature and humanity, investing it with value and honor which belongs to God alone. Why the desire to ascribe creation to “mother nature?” It is not merely evolutionary thought, but a denial of God’s rights, transcendence, wisdom, omnipotence, and glory. Ultimately it removes God from His own creation.

Animism is the belief that animals, plants, rivers, mountains, and nature possess a spiritual dimension. The form which animism takes will vary, depending on the geography, religious background, spiritual history, cultural background, and worldview of a particular group who practice it. See https://truthandtidings.com/2017/07/a-christian-worldview-mother-nature/ Recall the scandal of the pachamama statue placed before the main altar of St Peter’s in the Vatican at the Synod on the Amazonin 2019. In Inca mythology she is an "Earth Mother" type goddess, and a fertility goddess who presides over planting and harvesting, embodies the mountains, and causes earthquakes. It was claimed by the Vatican that pachamama represented life and motherhood. But is that the way the indigenous peoples saw it?

Another great danger for the Church in these times is the cancerous spread of a false teaching called “indifferentism:” that all philosophical opinions, all religions, and all ethical doctrines regarding life are equally true and valuable. It denies the duty of man to worship God by believing and practicing the one true religion of Jesus Christ. This religious indifferentism is to be distinguished from political indifferentism, which is applied to the policy of a state that treats all the religions within its borders as being on an equal footing before the law of the country. The denial of religious truth violates the law of non-contradiction. In logic, the law of non-contradiction states that contradictory propositions cannot both be true in the same sense at the same time. For example Jesus Christ IS God made flesh; Jesus Christ is NOT God made flesh cannot both be true and it makes a big difference which one is. The Catholic religion is the true religion not because of human beings but because of Who Jesus Christ is: God made flesh. This is my beloved Son. Listen to Him. Matthew 17:5 Jesus is Lord.

BACK TO LIST